‘Are you priest or parson?’

Fifty years ago on Parson Cross, a large housing estate on the outskirts of Sheffield, we did a lot of funerals. And we visited the family in their home before the funeral. On this occasion the husband was ‘C of E’ but the wife and her family were ‘Catholic’. So I went to do the funeral visit and was greeted by the widow and her mother. The old lady looked at me somewhat suspiciously, in my black suit and Roman collar. ‘Are you priest or parson?’ she asked. ‘The priest,’ I replied confidently, for what young Anglo-Catholic would have thought of himself as a ‘parson’? Reassured, the old lady gestured to one of the grand children. ‘Fetch an ash tray for Father’, she ordered.

Anglo-Catholics had been arguing for decades that they were proper priests in the Catholic sense of the word. They claimed the authority of the Book of Common Prayer which, they pointed out, makes a clear distinction in its services between what a ‘Minister’ may do (a Deacon or lay person) and when a ‘Priest’ is required. But ordinary people remained stubbornly unconvinced. So from time to time, having introduced myself as ‘the priest from St X’s’ I would received a puzzled look and the comment ‘But I thought ‘priest’ was Catholic … ‘ But I think that fifty years ago an Evangelical Anglican clergyman who introduced himself as the ‘Minister from St X’s’ would probably have got the same puzzled look, and the protesting remark, ‘But we’re Church of England!’ For in common parlance, Catholic clerics were ‘priests’, the C of E had ‘vicars’ and the Free Churches ‘ministers’.

In the 1980 Alternative Service Book the Evangelicals managed to smuggle in the word ‘Presbyter’ in the title of the Ordination Service, which they felt somehow distanced the ordained ministry of the C of E from that of the Roman Catholic Church. A bishop told me that he had had younger clergy complaining that they had to be ordained ‘twice’ (as Deacon and Priest). Certainly I recall attending an Ordination to the Priesthood at St Paul’s Cathedral where the vicars and congregations of some of the Deacons being priested were not present. (Presumably they could not spare the time for this unnecessary piece of ritual.) And by the ’90’s a friend remarked ruefully that the C of E now only used the word ‘priest’ in the expression ‘woman priest’. Given such uncertainly over even the word ‘priest’, let alone his role and ministry, the hundreds of clergy who left the C of E from then on accepted Catholic ordination without the qualms that a previous generation might have had.

A friend recently sent me a copy of this advert from the Church Times asking if I understood it. (For those who do not know, the ‘Church Times’ is a weekly newspaper of the Church of England founded in he 19th century. For a long time it took a consistently Anglo-Catholic line, but a change of editorial policy led to it becoming the mouthpiece of the ‘Liberal Establishment’ wing of the C of E. The ‘Church of England Newspaper’ leans towards the Evangelical wing of the C of E. The ‘Church Times’ should not be confused with ‘Not the Church Times’ – a one-off publication in the last century which satirised the C of E in all its manifestations. But what of that recent advert?

jobs.CHURCH TIMES

_______________ _____________________

JOB OF THE WEEK

____________________________________

Lead Ordained Ministry Enabler

Yorkshire and Lincs

This is a new opportunity to take on a strategic oversight role

 which will seek to develop personalized and  integrated

pathways from ordination through to experienced Oversight

Ministry.

What on earth, my friend asked, did this advert tell us about the new understanding of ordained ministry and leadership in the parishes? Had bishops, priests and deacons, which the Prayer Book asserts existed from the time of the Apostles, been superseded by a new and more modern pattern?

The job would seem to involve devising and organising training courses for those recently ordained through to their entering upon ‘Oversight Ministry’. The use of capital letters would suggest that this is a recognised position in the C of E. My friend had come across Area Dean, Associate Vicar, Worship Leader and Pastoral Assistant – but Oversight Minister was a new one. The New Testament uses the word ‘episcope’ for ‘oversight’ – the pastoral care of the Church in a particular area – and we see it for example in the ministry of St Paul as he cares for the unity, doctrinal orthodoxy and way of life of the Christian Church at Ephesus, Philippi, Corinth and so on. Is this Oversight Ministry another name for the role and work of the Bishop? Could the C of E be identifying newly ordained clergy for a future as Bishops. Certainly this would not be something new. Forty years ago some clergy were invited on a residential weekend (hosted at Windsor, I think) and, although it was always a bit hush-hush one got the impression that these were men who were destined for the hierarchy.

The truth is rather more mundane. For ‘Oversight Minister’ read ‘Team Rector’. I discovered some months ago that a certain northern diocese had received a substantial grant from the Church Commissioners to develop a new form of Team Ministry. The grouping of parishes together to form a single new parish is not new. In the 19th century with the rapid growth of population and the building of new housing estates, parishes were divided and subdivided, new churches built and incumbents (vicars) appointed. With church attendance and vocations to the clergy falling from the 1960’s onwards, a period of retrenchment began. Four parishes would be combined into a single Team Ministry parish; none of the churches would be closed at this stage, and each would have its own Team Vicar. But one of the clergy would be the Team Rector – with care (oversight) of all the congregations and clergy in the parish. In time, as clergy numbers fell, so the Team might lose one of its clerics, with the four churches of the team now being served by three clergy. Surely, just what happens now in the Catholic Church, where a single priest celebrates three Sunday Mass in three neighbouring parishes! But the parishes of the C of E were far more disparate and therein lay the problem.

A recent newspaper article highlighted the difficulties in the Diocese of Truro, pointing to a vicar who was now obliged to celebrate a Solemn Mass with incense in one of his churches followed by a Family Service in the next parish – where, the article joked, the congregation would leave if there was a whiff of such High Churchery! But what if the priest does not regard all the outward signs and ceremonies of worship as indifferent, but rather speaking and showing forth doctrine, belief – and ultimately truth? Ah well, that’s a problem. And it’s why Anglo-Catholics were less and less at ease with Team Ministry. Not without reason, as it turns out.

The diocese where I grew up was not exactly stuffed with Anglo-Catholic parishes. I went recently to the website of one, to find that on three Sundays in the month their service is a ‘High Church Eucharist service’ (I kid you not). You’ve guessed, they are now part of a Team Ministry! Team Rectors are usually chosen from the liberal tradition. It is widely held that they will be able to keep the ‘High Church’ in the parish going because they wear the vestments – although they will probably let it be known that they prefer to be addressed as ‘Dave’ rather than ‘Father’. There may be a sticky moment when the Bishop appoints a women as the Team Rector. But then very few people at St Ichabod’s want to be accused of misogyny. Evangelicals do become Team Rectors; I remember one parish where the cleric concerned was able to abandon the ‘robes’ because, so he claimed in the Parish Magazine, they got in the way when he wanted to play the guitar.

As I look back over this article I see moments of bitterness – or perhaps frustration – creeping in. This is a bit strange; it is after all, thirteen years ago that I became a Catholic. I have never regretted the decision, and I am, more or less, at ease with C of E clergy and C of E services when I attend them. From time to time I ponder on what might have been had the Catholic Movement not become a Party, and had convinced the C of E of its true past and its hoped-for future. And I hope my Catholic friends may have some greater insight and understanding of where we ‘converts’ are coming from.

Unknown's avatar

About Scott Anderson

Formerly an Anglican priest (ordained 1975) I was received into the Catholic Church in February 2012, and ordained to the Diaconate on 27th July 2013 and on 29th October 2013 was ordained to the priesthood by the Archbishop of Southwark Peter Smith. After a spell in London (Precious Blood, Borough) I became parish priest of Pont Rémy in the Diocese of Amiens, northern France. I am deeply committed to the Ordinariate as a gift of the Holy Spirit in the search for unity. Like many Ordinariate members I feel a personal gratitude to the late Pope Benedict, together with loyalty to our Holy Father, Pope Leo. My blog tries to make a small contribution to the growth of the Ordinariate by asking questions (and proposing some answers) about the 'Anglican Patrimony'. I shall be ever grateful for the years in France, a wonderful ending to the years of parish ministry. Back in the UK I am attached, very happily, to the parish of Holy Trinity, Dorchester (HTD) and help out where needed in the Catholic parishes of South Dorset.
This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to ‘Are you priest or parson?’

  1. Alan Cooke's avatar Alan Cooke says:

    Hello Scott, and Michaelmas greetings from Malta.

    Thanks for your latest blog. Please allow me to make a couple of comments.

    The Preface to the first Anglican ordination rite (1550) roundly declared (I quote from memory) that ‘it is evident unto all men diligently reading holy scripture that from the apostles’ time there have been these orders of ministers in Christ’s Church: bishops, priests and deacons’. It went on to declare that the intention of the rites contained in it was to ensure that these three orders should be continued in the Church of England.

    As far as I recall, this declaration was not taken into account in Pope Leo XIII’s declaration of 1897 that Anglican orders were and are ‘absolutely null and utterly void’. However, and as your present blog argues, it is now redundant in view of the present-day Church of England’s widespread departure from anything resembling apostolic faith and practice.

    Secondly, and as Chaucer makes clear, there is nothing inherently protestant in the word ‘parson’, and both before and after the English Reformation a parson had to be a priest, although not all priests were parsons. The titles ‘parson’ (aka ‘rector’) and ‘vicar’ were all in use before the Reformation and related to a parish priest’s entitlement to all or only some of the tithes which provided his income.

    I make these points simply as a matter of history, and not in any way to challenge the substance of your blog. If the Church of England ever was capable of conferring the historic priesthood and episcopate (as you and I both once believed), it must surely be clear, as it is from your article, that it no longer is.

    • Alan – many thanks for your greetings and comments. I read recently an American priest had been ordained “as a minister in the C of E’. But the C of E never claimed to ordain ‘ministers’ (or even ‘Ministers’) but Bishops, Priests and Deacons’ in Christ’s Church. The sensitivity of Pope Benedict is, I think, to be seen in Anglicanorum Coetibus where the clergy of the C of E are referred to as ‘Anglican Bishops, Priests and Deacons. The judgement of the Catholic Church as voiced by Pope Leo XIII was that the C of E’s ordinations were not able to confer those orders. I accept that and accepted Catholic ordination without reserve. But in conversation and discussion I talk about my days as an ‘Anglican priest’ and not as a ‘Minister’.

      It is I think that in all the years of debate about whether women could become priests the C of E refused resolutely to examine the nature of priesthood – for that would have opened up massive divisions. Thus one might say now that ‘the C of E ordains women and men to the priesthood (or presbyterate) , whatever they think that is.’ Many of us could not live with that.

Leave a Reply